The Chain of Custody: How One Broken Link Can Set a Killer Free

On June 12, 1994, Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman were murdered outside Nicole's Brentwood home. The evidence against Nicole's ex-husband, former NFL star O.J. Simpson, was substantial: blood at the scene, a glove matching one found at Simpson's estate, and DNA evidence.

Yet on October 3, 1995, the jury acquitted Simpson of both murders after just four hours of deliberation. The "trial of the century" had become, in large part, a referendum on how evidence is handled.

THE CHAIN OF CUSTODY: Chain of custody is the documented, unbroken sequence of possession of evidence — from the moment it is collected at a crime scene to its presentation in court. Every person who handles the evidence must be logged. Any gap in that chain creates the possibility that evidence was tampered with, contaminated, or substituted.

THE FAILURES IN SIMPSON: Defense attorneys Johnnie Cochran and Barry Scheck systematically attacked the chain of custody:

• A vial of Simpson's reference blood sample showed 1.5 mL less blood than had been drawn — suggesting some had been removed and planted
• LAPD criminalist Dennis Fung admitted to making collection errors and storing evidence improperly
• A bloodstained sock found in Simpson's bedroom tested positive for EDTA — a preservative found in reference blood samples, not fresh blood
• The infamous glove had been handled by Detective Mark Fuhrman, who was later caught on tape making racist statements — raising jury suspicions about planting

THE VERDICT: The jury's acquittal reflected not a belief that Simpson was innocent, but a reasonable doubt that the evidence itself could be trusted.

THE LESSON: The Simpson case fundamentally changed evidence handling protocols across U.S. law enforcement. It demonstrated that physical evidence — no matter how compelling — is only as trustworthy as the hands through which it passed.

Tell us your thoughts in the comments below.

Please like and subscribe for more investigations from The Evidence Log.