Cold Case DNA: How Evidence Stored for Decades Is Solving Old Murders

When a detective collected a rape kit in 1985, DNA profiling didn't exist. When a criminalist scraped a fingernail in 1978, the polymerase chain reaction technique that could amplify vanishingly small DNA samples hadn't been invented. The evidence sat in storage — boxes in evidence rooms, envelopes on shelves, refrigerated samples in forgotten corners of police departments.

Decades later, that evidence is solving murders.

THE TECHNOLOGY LEAP: Modern DNA analysis techniques can extract profiles from:

• Touch DNA — skin cells left by brief contact
• Degraded samples that would have been unusable 20 years ago
• Mixed samples containing DNA from multiple contributors
• Bloodstains that have been exposed to heat, humidity, and time

Combined with national and consumer DNA databases, these techniques can match profiles against millions of people — including relatives of the unknown suspect through forensic genealogy.

NOTABLE COLD CASES SOLVED:

• The 1976 murder of 18-year-old Angie Dodge in Idaho Falls: solved in 2019 using forensic genealogy from DNA preserved for 43 years. Brian Dripps Sr. confessed.
• The 1987 murders of Jay Cook and Tanya Van Cuylenborg in Washington State: solved in 2018 using DNA from evidence stored for 31 years. William Earl Talbott II was convicted.
• Dozens of 1970s–1990s murders across the U.S. are being solved annually

THE RAPE KIT BACKLOG: A parallel crisis: hundreds of thousands of untested rape kits sit in police storage facilities across America. Testing programs in New York, Detroit, and other cities have connected kits to serial offenders — including murders committed years after the original assault.

THE LESSON: Evidence storage is not just an administrative function — it is an act of justice deferred. How evidence is preserved today determines which cases can be solved tomorrow.

Tell us your thoughts in the comments below.

Please like and subscribe for more investigations from The Evidence Log.